Quote comparison: MRMW-RFQ-1142

3 quotes. Expiry flags use 2026-11-19 as today.

Compare

Summary

SupplierLines totalFreightTotalLead time daysPayment termsValid untilMissing terms
Red Creek Steel Supply$9,169.11$285.00$9,454.1114Net 302026-12-120
Panhandle Bar and Plate$8,402.00$300.00$8,702.0035not statednot stated8
Cedar Flats Metals Service$8,900.00$0.00$8,900.0031% 10 Net 302026-11-293

Shaded cells show the lowest total and the shortest lead time. A person makes the call, not this page.

By part

Our partRed Creek Steel SupplyPanhandle Bar and PlateCedar Flats Metals Service
MR-3001
Units differ (CWT, FT, EA). Compare line totals, not unit prices.
$5,049.11
51.26 CWT @ $98.50
$4,512.00
480 FT @ $9.40
$4,750.00
40 EA @ $118.75
MR-3002
Units differ (SHEET, EA). Compare line totals, not unit prices.
$4,120.00
10 SHEET @ $412.00
$3,890.00
10 EA @ $389.00
$4,050.00
10 EA @ $405.00

Missing terms

Required fieldRed Creek Steel SupplyPanhandle Bar and PlateCedar Flats Metals Service
Supplier name✓✓✓
Street✓MISSING✓
City✓MISSING✓
State✓MISSING✓
ZIP✓MISSING✓
Contact name✓✓MISSING
Contact email✓✓MISSING
Contact phone✓✓MISSING
Quote number✓MISSING✓
Quote date✓✓✓
Valid until✓MISSING✓
Payment terms✓MISSING✓
Freight terms✓✓✓
Freight cost✓✓✓
Lead time days✓✓✓
Minimum order✓MISSING✓
Line qty, unit, unit price✓✓✓

Flags

Margin

SupplierTotal15% margin20% margin25% margin30% margin
Red Creek Steel Supply$9,454.11$11,122.48$11,817.64$12,605.48$13,505.87
Panhandle Bar and Plate$8,702.00$10,237.65$10,877.50$11,602.67$12,431.43
Cedar Flats Metals Service$8,900.00$10,470.59$11,125.00$11,866.67$12,714.29

Sell price = total / (1 - margin). Gross margin is the share of the sell price you keep, so a 20% margin on a $1,000 total needs a sell price of $1,250.00, not $1,200.00.

Red Creek Steel Supply

Supplier

Name
Red Creek Steel Supply
Address
2210 Rail Spur Road
Building C
Sweetwater Draw, TX 79555
Phone
325-555-0187

Contact

Name
Rosa Delgado
Email
rdelgado@redcreeksteel.example
Phone
325-555-0187

Quote

Number
RC-24117
Date
2026-11-12
Valid until
2026-12-12
Our RFQ
MRMW-RFQ-1142
Currency
USD

Terms

Payment
Net 30
Freight
FOB shipping point. Prepay and add.
Freight cost
$285.00
Lead time (days)
14
Minimum order
$0.00

Lines

LineOur partSupplier partDescriptionQtyUOMUnit priceExt priceCheck
1MR-3001not stated4140 HR Round Bar 2.000" x 12' (40 pc)51.26CWT$98.50$5,049.11✓ ok
2MR-3002not statedA36 HR Plate .500 x 48 x 9610SHEET$412.00$4,120.00✓ ok
Lines total$9,169.11
Freight$285.00
Total$9,454.11

Panhandle Bar and Plate

Supplier

Name
Panhandle Bar and Plate
Address
not stated
Phone
806-555-0142

Contact

Name
Mike Arnett
Email
marnett@panhandlebar.example
Phone
806-555-0142

Quote

Number
not stated
Date
2026-11-13
Valid until
not stated
Our RFQ
MRMW-RFQ-1142
Currency
USD

Terms

Payment
not stated
Freight
Added to invoice
Freight cost
$300.00
Lead time (days)
35
Minimum order
not stated

Lines

LineOur partSupplier partDescriptionQtyUOMUnit priceExt priceCheck
1MR-3001not stated4140 2" round, 12' random lengths, 40 pcs480FT$9.40$4,512.00 computedcomputed
2MR-3002not statedA36 plate 1/2" x 48 x 9610EA$389.00$3,890.00 computedcomputed
Lines total$8,402.00
Freight$300.00
Total$8,702.00

Cedar Flats Metals Service

Supplier

Name
Cedar Flats Metals Service
Address
118 Mesquite Lane
Cedar Flats, TX 79560
Phone
not stated

Contact

Name
not stated
Email
not stated
Phone
not stated

Quote

Number
CFM-8832
Date
2026-11-14
Valid until
2026-11-29
Our RFQ
MRMW-RFQ-1142
Currency
USD

Terms

Payment
1% 10 Net 30
Freight
Delivered on their truck
Freight cost
$0.00
Lead time (days)
3
Minimum order
$150.00

Lines

LineOur partSupplier partDescriptionQtyUOMUnit priceExt priceCheck
1MR-300141402RD124140 HR RD 2.000 X 12FT40EA$118.75$4,750.00✓ ok
2MR-3002A36PL500-4896A36 PL .500 X 48 X 9610EA$405.00$4,050.00
quote says $4,500.00
MISMATCH
3not on our RFQSAWCUTSAW CUT CHARGE40EA$2.50$100.00✓ ok
Lines total$8,900.00
Freight$0.00
Total$8,900.00