Quote comparison: MRMW-RFQ-1142
3 quotes. Expiry flags use 2026-11-19 as today.
Compare
Summary
| Supplier | Lines total | Freight | Total | Lead time days | Payment terms | Valid until | Missing terms |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Red Creek Steel Supply | $9,169.11 | $285.00 | $9,454.11 | 14 | Net 30 | 2026-12-12 | 0 |
| Panhandle Bar and Plate | $8,402.00 | $300.00 | $8,702.00 | 35 | not stated | not stated | 8 |
| Cedar Flats Metals Service | $8,900.00 | $0.00 | $8,900.00 | 3 | 1% 10 Net 30 | 2026-11-29 | 3 |
Shaded cells show the lowest total and the shortest lead time. A person makes the call, not this page.
By part
| Our part | Red Creek Steel Supply | Panhandle Bar and Plate | Cedar Flats Metals Service |
|---|---|---|---|
| MR-3001 Units differ (CWT, FT, EA). Compare line totals, not unit prices. | $5,049.11 51.26 CWT @ $98.50 | $4,512.00 480 FT @ $9.40 | $4,750.00 40 EA @ $118.75 |
| MR-3002 Units differ (SHEET, EA). Compare line totals, not unit prices. | $4,120.00 10 SHEET @ $412.00 | $3,890.00 10 EA @ $389.00 | $4,050.00 10 EA @ $405.00 |
Missing terms
| Required field | Red Creek Steel Supply | Panhandle Bar and Plate | Cedar Flats Metals Service |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supplier name | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Street | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| City | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| State | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| ZIP | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| Contact name | ✓ | ✓ | MISSING |
| Contact email | ✓ | ✓ | MISSING |
| Contact phone | ✓ | ✓ | MISSING |
| Quote number | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| Quote date | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Valid until | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| Payment terms | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| Freight terms | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Freight cost | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Lead time days | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
| Minimum order | ✓ | MISSING | ✓ |
| Line qty, unit, unit price | ✓ | ✓ | ✓ |
Flags
- Red Creek Steel Supply: Note from the quote: Freight cost is an estimate.
- Red Creek Steel Supply: Note from the quote: Prices subject to mill surcharge at time of shipment.
- Red Creek Steel Supply: Note from the quote: Bar is priced by weight: 40 pieces, about 5,126 lb.
- Panhandle Bar and Plate: Note from the quote: Quote is an email, not a formal quote.
- Panhandle Bar and Plate: Note from the quote: Bar is 12' random lengths. Pieces may not all be 12 ft.
- Panhandle Bar and Plate: Note from the quote: Lead time quoted as 4-5 weeks. Used the high end.
- Panhandle Bar and Plate: Note from the quote: Freight is approximate: 'around $300'.
- Cedar Flats Metals Service: Line 2 math does not match: 10 x $405.00 = $4,050.00. Quote says $4,500.00.
- Cedar Flats Metals Service: Line 3 is not on our RFQ: SAW CUT CHARGE ($100.00)
- Cedar Flats Metals Service: Note from the quote: Valid for 15 days from the quote date.
- Cedar Flats Metals Service: Note from the quote: Saw cut charge was not on our RFQ.
Margin
| Supplier | Total | 15% margin | 20% margin | 25% margin | 30% margin |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Red Creek Steel Supply | $9,454.11 | $11,122.48 | $11,817.64 | $12,605.48 | $13,505.87 |
| Panhandle Bar and Plate | $8,702.00 | $10,237.65 | $10,877.50 | $11,602.67 | $12,431.43 |
| Cedar Flats Metals Service | $8,900.00 | $10,470.59 | $11,125.00 | $11,866.67 | $12,714.29 |
Sell price = total / (1 - margin). Gross margin is the share of the sell price you keep, so a 20% margin on a $1,000 total needs a sell price of $1,250.00, not $1,200.00.
Red Creek Steel Supply
Supplier
- Name
- Red Creek Steel Supply
- Address
- 2210 Rail Spur Road
Building C
Sweetwater Draw, TX 79555 - Phone
- 325-555-0187
Contact
- Name
- Rosa Delgado
- rdelgado@redcreeksteel.example
- Phone
- 325-555-0187
Quote
- Number
- RC-24117
- Date
- 2026-11-12
- Valid until
- 2026-12-12
- Our RFQ
- MRMW-RFQ-1142
- Currency
- USD
Terms
- Payment
- Net 30
- Freight
- FOB shipping point. Prepay and add.
- Freight cost
- $285.00
- Lead time (days)
- 14
- Minimum order
- $0.00
Lines
| Line | Our part | Supplier part | Description | Qty | UOM | Unit price | Ext price | Check |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MR-3001 | not stated | 4140 HR Round Bar 2.000" x 12' (40 pc) | 51.26 | CWT | $98.50 | $5,049.11 | ✓ ok |
| 2 | MR-3002 | not stated | A36 HR Plate .500 x 48 x 96 | 10 | SHEET | $412.00 | $4,120.00 | ✓ ok |
| Lines total | $9,169.11 | |||||||
| Freight | $285.00 | |||||||
| Total | $9,454.11 | |||||||
Panhandle Bar and Plate
Supplier
- Name
- Panhandle Bar and Plate
- Address
- not stated
- Phone
- 806-555-0142
Contact
- Name
- Mike Arnett
- marnett@panhandlebar.example
- Phone
- 806-555-0142
Quote
- Number
- not stated
- Date
- 2026-11-13
- Valid until
- not stated
- Our RFQ
- MRMW-RFQ-1142
- Currency
- USD
Terms
- Payment
- not stated
- Freight
- Added to invoice
- Freight cost
- $300.00
- Lead time (days)
- 35
- Minimum order
- not stated
Lines
| Line | Our part | Supplier part | Description | Qty | UOM | Unit price | Ext price | Check |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MR-3001 | not stated | 4140 2" round, 12' random lengths, 40 pcs | 480 | FT | $9.40 | $4,512.00 computed | computed |
| 2 | MR-3002 | not stated | A36 plate 1/2" x 48 x 96 | 10 | EA | $389.00 | $3,890.00 computed | computed |
| Lines total | $8,402.00 | |||||||
| Freight | $300.00 | |||||||
| Total | $8,702.00 | |||||||
Cedar Flats Metals Service
Supplier
- Name
- Cedar Flats Metals Service
- Address
- 118 Mesquite Lane
Cedar Flats, TX 79560 - Phone
- not stated
Contact
- Name
- not stated
- not stated
- Phone
- not stated
Quote
- Number
- CFM-8832
- Date
- 2026-11-14
- Valid until
- 2026-11-29
- Our RFQ
- MRMW-RFQ-1142
- Currency
- USD
Terms
- Payment
- 1% 10 Net 30
- Freight
- Delivered on their truck
- Freight cost
- $0.00
- Lead time (days)
- 3
- Minimum order
- $150.00
Lines
| Line | Our part | Supplier part | Description | Qty | UOM | Unit price | Ext price | Check |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | MR-3001 | 41402RD12 | 4140 HR RD 2.000 X 12FT | 40 | EA | $118.75 | $4,750.00 | ✓ ok |
| 2 | MR-3002 | A36PL500-4896 | A36 PL .500 X 48 X 96 | 10 | EA | $405.00 | $4,050.00 quote says $4,500.00 | MISMATCH |
| 3 | not on our RFQ | SAWCUT | SAW CUT CHARGE | 40 | EA | $2.50 | $100.00 | ✓ ok |
| Lines total | $8,900.00 | |||||||
| Freight | $0.00 | |||||||
| Total | $8,900.00 | |||||||